Hello Emily, the two can be alright, but I would lighten each by 25% to change the contrast a tiny bit. And they would Equally be good with navy, I’ve noticed AG go substantially gray in some rooms, indicating it’s a organic companion to navy (north struggling with rooms specially). http://dantewvrnj.affiliatblogger.com/26004678/new-step-by-step-map-for-best-sherwin-williams-exterior-paint